When to Move a Stop Loss to Break Even
When to move a stop loss to break even: the triggers disagree, the entry price is not really break even once costs are paid, and how to test your own rule.
There is no settled answer. The published triggers run from never moving it at all, through 1R of open profit, to a confirmed higher low above your entry, and two of them tell the same trader opposite things at the same moment in the same trade.
Moving a stop to your entry price does not usually leave you flat. A fill at the entry price is still a round trip, and it still pays the spread and any commission.
What does moving your stop loss to break even mean?
It means moving the stop from where you first placed it to your entry price, once the trade has gone your way, so the position can no longer lose money. The appeal is that the trade becomes, in the usual phrase, risk free.
The honest name for it is "almost break even". Exit at the exact price you entered at and you have paid the spread twice over the round trip, plus any commission, plus whatever slippage the fill carried. tradingheroes.com builds that into its definition, calling it the entry price "plus a little profit to cover costs like slippage, the spread and commission". fxssi.com puts the same point in its opening definition: in forex "this level would ideally be somewhere close to your entry point, after you factor in your spreads".
Several of the sources never raise it, and still tell a reader to put the stop at the entry price.
When should you move your stop loss to break even?
The published triggers, with the date printed on each page:
| Source, date as the page prints it | Its trigger | Does the page name any trading cost? |
|---|---|---|
| dailypriceaction.com, Updated October 3, 2022 | Never. "The short answer is, never – there is never a good time to move your stop loss to breakeven." Its alternative is to move the stop "to a strategic level – one that the market has deemed important" | No |
| fxssi.com, November 14, 2021 | Depends on the motive. If the motive is fear, "the answer to when you should move your stop loss to breakeven is this: Never!" If it is to lock in profit, "first make sure you've made enough profit on that trade. This is often when the price has hit your first target", which it says is 50 pips for some traders and "1.5 times your original stop loss" for others | Yes, once, in its definition |
| tradingheroes.com, July 30, 2025 | 1R as the default. "If you don't know where to start, move your stop loss to breakeven once price hits 1R." The threshold can be measured in "Pips, points or dollars, depending on what market you're trading", as a multiple of risk, or as a percentage of the account | Yes. Spread, commission, slippage and fees, in two places |
| zitaplus.com, undated | Explicitly not 1R. "Instead of moving to breakeven as soon as price gains 1R, set a strict threshold, such as 1.5R or 2R, before touching your stop." Its other trigger is a higher low "confirmed by a structural breakout", after which the stop goes "just beneath that fresh swing low" | Yes, under its own heading, "Friction and Spread Costs" |
| edgeflo.com, Mar 10, 2026 | Only a confirmed higher low. "Do not move your stop to break even until price has created a confirmed higher low above or near your entry. If the new higher low sits at or above your entry, your stop naturally lands at break even or better. If it sits below your entry, keep your original stop" | No |
| xabcdtrading.com, April 15, 2023 | Argues against the "+1" variant, where a trader locks in a single pip. "The +1 would assume it's forex and they are locking in 1 more pip higher than break even. On a standard contract this would be locking in $10 worth of profit" | No |
zitaplus.com is a broker: its own navigation lists account types and a "Spreads & Swap Rates" page. edgeflo.com sells a trading tool, and the article carries a section headed "How EdgeFlo Helps You Time Break Even Moves".
None of those triggers is a recommendation here.
Should you move it at all?
Both arguments are published.
For: it removes the remaining risk from an open trade, and it removes the stress that comes with it. zitaplus.com states the appeal plainly, that the move "eliminates downside dollar risk" and "removes stress".
Against: it converts trades that would have worked into flat ones. dailypriceaction.com's version is an argument about levels rather than about psychology. "Remember that once you enter a trade your entry price becomes trivial. All that matters from that point on is your target and an invalidation level." A stop at your entry price, on that reading, is anchored to a number only you can see. The same page adds that a break-even stop "only serves to protect their win rate", which it calls "one of the more meaningless statistics for a trader".
Two published alternatives. zitaplus.com would rather you did not move the stop: close "30% to 50% of your position" at a 1R to 1.5R target and leave the stop where it was. fxssi.com uses a partial close too, but as a companion rather than a replacement: take some profit off and move the stop. dailypriceaction.com's alternative is to move the stop to a level the market made rather than to your entry.
Is 1R the right trigger?
At 1R of open profit, tradingheroes.com says move the stop: "If you don't know where to start, move your stop loss to breakeven once price hits 1R." zitaplus.com says that exact moment is the mistake, and sets its own threshold at "1.5R or 2R, before touching your stop", with a formula it prints as "Breakeven Trigger Price (Long) = Entry Price + (m x Initial Risk)".
They are answering a question whose answer depends on something neither of them knows: how often price comes back to your entry after 1R, on the instrument and the timeframe you trade, with your entries.
If you use R as a unit, pin down your own definition of it first. It is also a different idea from the break-even win rate.
How much do you have to add to cover costs?
Two sources put a number on it, and they point in opposite directions.
tradingheroes.com moves the stop above the entry price: "I usually move Forex trades to the opening price, +3 pips profit to account for any slippage and fees." zitaplus.com moves it below, so that ordinary spread widening does not trigger it, with "Buffered Stop Level = Entry Price - (0.5 x ATR)". Read its paragraph in full, though, and that page offers both directions: it says to "place your adjusted stop slightly below your entry point, or wait to move it until you can trail it into actual profit above entry".
A third source lands above entry for a different reason. edgeflo.com's own GBP/USD walkthrough enters at 1.2700 and, when a higher low forms at 1.2715, puts the stop at 1.2710, which the page calls "effectively at break even with a small buffer". That is ten pips above the entry price, and the reason given is structure rather than cost. An article titled "Break Even Stop Loss: When to Move It" never, in its own example, puts a stop at the entry price. The walkthrough is hypothetical.
No single number works, because the spread and the commission are per symbol and per broker. A figure that is right on EUR/USD in one account is wrong on gold in another. You can measure yours.
What is the difference between moving to break even and trailing a stop?
One move to one level, against a stop that keeps moving. edgeflo.com frames it by intent, saying that break even says you do not want to lose money on this trade, while trailing says you want to lock in as much profit as possible while the trend continues.
The two are not kept so cleanly apart everywhere. tradingheroes.com puts it the other way round: "In effect, moving your stop loss to breakeven is a type of trailing stop." Both readings are defensible, and the practical difference is only whether you intend to move the stop once or repeatedly.
fxssi.com cannot do this in a single order on MT4, so it tells readers to split the trade into two orders and put the take profit on one, which is a platform workaround rather than a rule. xabcdtrading.com is a NinjaTrader post. Decide the rule first; the mechanics change with the software.
How do you test a break-even rule?
Step the same trades twice and compare the same numbers both times. Once with the rule, once without, on the same setups and the same history.
tradingheroes.com publishes that method under its own heading, "How to Backtest Moving Your Stop Loss to Breakeven", and the procedure is two passes: in the first you "create a trading plan without moving your stop loss" and "backtest that trading plan and find out what your baseline performance is", and in the second you "create a new trading plan where you move the stop loss to breakeven after X amount of profit" and compare.
Manual, bar by bar, makes the comparison honest here, because the thing you are testing is a decision you make in the middle of a trade. ChartLabs replays historical charts one bar at a time and lets you take practice trades as the bars arrive. Orders go in from the bar at the bottom of the chart, market, limit or stop, each carrying a stop loss, a take profit and a risk-reward reading. Two passes over the same stretch of history give you two sets of results built from the same setups.
Costs are part of the answer. ChartLabs applies commission and slippage per symbol, so the P&L reflects what trading actually costs, and the Trading Costs card reports Total Costs, Cost Drag and Avg Cost / Trade. Our own forex backtesting guide makes the same point about the spread from the other direction: "A strategy that shows 10 pips profit per trade with zero spread might break even with realistic spreads applied."
The Stats and Insights dashboard also reports Profit Lock Rate, Average Initial Risk and Breakeven Rate as their own numbers, so stop discipline shows up on its own rather than buried inside P&L.
What should you record?
For every trade the rule touched: the trigger you used, whether the stop was actually moved, whether the trade then closed at that stop, and whether price went on to reach the original target anyway.
zitaplus.com publishes the sourced version of this: "Review your last 50 to 100 trades in a spreadsheet or trade log. Look specifically at trades that hit your breakeven stop and track what price did next. If a large percentage of those trades eventually went on to hit your original profit target, your breakeven rules are choking off your profits and need adjusting."
tradingheroes.com lists what to compare between the two passes: win percentage, maximum drawdown, average profit per month or year, average winning trade, average losing trade, and the maximum number of losing trades in a row. Compare the same list both times or the comparison means nothing.
A note per trade is enough to carry the trigger you used. ChartLabs has a Notes column in the Orders panel and a note button on the chart while a trade is open, and notes come through in the CSV export.
What goes wrong?
Moving it before the market has made a new level. This is the common thread across the sources that argue against the move, and edgeflo.com states the condition: wait for a confirmed higher low above or near your entry, and if the higher low sits below your entry, keep the original stop.
Calling the entry price break even when it is not. Several sources tell a reader to put a stop at the entry price without naming a single trading cost. zitaplus.com, which does name them, puts the consequence in one sentence: "Even when an order fills at exact breakeven, you still pay bid-ask spreads, exchange fees, and commissions. Getting knocked out of five consecutive trades at breakeven does not leave your account balance unchanged."
Changing the trigger between trades. tradingheroes.com names this first: "Do the same thing on every trade: You cannot move to breakeven on some trades and not on others."
Ruining your own record. This is xabcdtrading.com's second objection, and it is about the data rather than the trade. Locking in a token profit, it argues, means "you're going to mess around and ruin a lot of your statistics. Your win ratio will be a lot higher, your average winner will be a lot smaller and all of these things will lead to dirty data." Its next paragraph adds that dirty data makes it "harder to find your mistakes". Two sources that disagree elsewhere land in the same place here: the break-even decision changes the numbers you review afterwards, so it has to be recorded as a rule rather than applied by feel.
That is also the argument for stepping it by hand. Our article on manual backtesting makes the same observation about this exact habit: "Do you move your stop loss? You'll catch it." For the background on why costs and fills decide whether any of this is measurable at all, backtesting accuracy covers it.
Where to start
Pick one trigger, write it down before you enter, and run the same stretch of history twice: once with it, once without. Then look at how many trades it touched and how many of those went on to the original target anyway.
Start a free trial and step a setup you already trade, both ways.
Related Topics
Related
Forex Backtesting: Test Your Strategy on Real Data
A practical guide to backtesting forex strategies: why session dynamics, spread variation, and pair-specific behavior change your results, what clean historical data actually means, and a five-step process for testing a strategy before you risk real capital.
Manual Backtesting Builds Better Traders
Stepping through historical charts by hand teaches what an automated backtest report cannot: pattern recognition, what a normal drawdown feels like, and the discipline to follow your own rules when it is uncomfortable.
Backtesting Accuracy: How Slippage and Data Quality Matter
Why backtest results and live results drift apart, and what actually closes the gap: clean tick data, honest spread assumptions, and commission and slippage modelled directly on every trade you log.